In our latest research note, A Bond Index Fund’s Balancing Act: Tracking Error and Cost, Vanguard researchers explain how our portfolio managers take on these challenges in support of their goal to closely track a benchmark.
Most managers of equity index funds typically seek to track a benchmark’s returns by buying all the stocks in it at market weights. That approach is not practical for many fixed income index fund managers due to the structure of the bond market, which features relatively higher cost and lower liquidity compared to equities.
The complexities of the bond market may leave investors with the impression that it’s not possible to effectively track a broad bond benchmark, but that’s a misconception, according to Josh Barrickman, a co-author of the research note and head of indexing for Vanguard Fixed Income Group.
“Bond index fund managers can target performance that closely matches the benchmark by aligning the fund’s key risk-factor exposures with the benchmark while also keeping transaction costs low,” Barrickman said. “It’s a balancing act between tracking error and costs. As the first company to offer a bond index fund, we’ve spent decades sharpening our techniques to offer some of the most competitive funds in the market.”
Bond index fund managers use several tools to balance the trade-offs between tracking error and costs. One is sampling, which involves selecting and weighting a subset of benchmark bonds to mimic the benchmark’s risk-factor exposures. Sampling alone won’t eliminate tracking error, however, so portfolio managers also use:
Multifactor risk models, which spot correlations among risk factors and assess portfolio risk at the macro and micro levels.
Optimization models, which are quantitative tools that seek asset combinations that can help meet an objective, such as minimizing tracking error versus a benchmark, while adhering to constraints, such as issuer concentration limits.
Barrickman and his co-authors compared the tracking error of portfolios that align duration, credit quality, and sector risk-factor exposures with the benchmark to those that randomly select the same number of bonds but don’t match benchmark risk exposures. They show that risk-aligned portfolios consistently reported lower tracking error.
“By building portfolios with bonds that best represent the risk-factor exposures of the benchmark, portfolio managers can buy fewer securities and bypass those that are expensive to trade,” Barrickman said. “Keeping transaction costs low helps us to deliver as much of the market return as possible to our investors.”
Vanguard’s global team of portfolio managers, traders, risk specialists, and credit analysts work every day to identify opportunities that strike a balance between transaction cost savings and closely tracking a benchmark.
For instance, when Ford Motor Company’s bonds were added to the Bloomberg U.S. Aggregate Bond Index in 2023, Vanguard’s bond index team initially delayed adding Ford’s full exposure, instead partially allocating to another auto issuer, General Motors. The two companies had similar risk characteristics, but Ford was trading at a premium as demand surged upon its addition to the index. By maintaining a higher allocation to GM until valuations normalized, Vanguard’s bond index team capitalized on a temporary mispricing while maintaining tight benchmark tracking.
“We’re always on the hunt for opportunities like this,” Barrickman said. “They help us fulfill one of our primary missions, which is to pursue benchmark returns while keeping costs low to give investors the best chance for investment success.”
Notes:
Notes:
For more information about Vanguard funds, visit vanguard.com to obtain a prospectus or, if available, a summary prospectus. Investment objectives, risks, charges, expenses, and other important information about a fund are contained in the prospectus; read and consider it carefully before investing.
All investing is subject to risk, including the possible loss of the money you invest. Past performance is not a guarantee of future results.
Investments in bonds are subject to interest rate, credit, and inflation risk. Bond funds are subject to the risk that an issuer will fail to make payments on time, and that bond prices will decline because of rising interest rates or negative perceptions of an issuer's ability to make payments.
All investing is subject to risk.
Publication date: March 2025
The information contained in this material may be subject to change without notice and may not represent the views and/or opinions of Vanguard Investments Canada Inc.
Certain statements contained in this material may be considered "forward-looking information" which may be material, involve risks, uncertainties or other assumptions and there is no guarantee that actual results will not differ significantly from those expressed in or implied by these statements. Factors include, but are not limited to, general global financial market conditions, interest and foreign exchange rates, economic and political factors, competition, legal or regulatory changes and catastrophic events. Any predictions, projections, estimates or forecasts should be construed as general investment or market information and no representation is being made that any investor will, or is likely to, achieve returns similar to those mentioned herein.
While the information contained in this material has been compiled from proprietary and non-proprietary sources believed to be reliable, no representation or warranty, express or implied, is made by The Vanguard Group, Inc., its subsidiaries or affiliates, or any other person (collectively, "The Vanguard Group") as to its accuracy, completeness, timeliness or reliability. The Vanguard Group takes no responsibility for any errors and omissions contained herein and accepts no liability whatsoever for any loss arising from any use of, or reliance on, this material.
This material is not a recommendation, offer or solicitation to buy or sell any security, including any security of any investment fund or any other financial instrument. The information contained in this material is not investment advice and is not tailored to the needs or circumstances of any investor, nor does the information constitute business, financial, tax, legal, regulatory, accounting or any other advice.
The information contained in this material may not be specific to the context of the Canadian capital markets and may contain data and analysis specific to non-Canadian markets and products.
The information contained in this material is for informational purposes only and should not be used as the basis of any investment recommendation. Investors should consult a financial, tax and/or other professional advisor for information applicable to their specific situation.
In this material, references to "Vanguard" are provided for convenience only and may refer to, where applicable, only The Vanguard Group, Inc., and/or may include its subsidiaries or affiliates, including Vanguard Investments Canada Inc.